Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s magic is just not working. With lower than three weeks till the elections, Turkey’s populist chief has made up little floor in opposition to Kemal Kilicdaroglu, the candidate of the primary opposition alliance, within the presidential race. (Parliament will even be up for grabs.) Most polls give Mr Kilicdaroglu an edge within the first spherical on Might 14th and see him successful a run-off two weeks later. Mr Erdogan is attempting to regain reputation by dipping into the general public purse. However he’s additionally searching for assist overseas, balancing, as he has achieved over the previous decade, between NATO allies, Russia and different autocracies, all whereas flexing his muscle tissues at house.

PREMIUM

Up to now couple of months, his authorities has waved by Finland’s accession to NATO, which it had been blocking since final summer time; banned firms from transport sanctioned items by Turkey to Russia; and courted Western traders whom it as soon as spurned. However Mr Erdogan has additionally assured his supporters that Turkey not cares what Western international locations consider its overseas coverage, and accused the West of backing his rivals. “Their hostile stance towards Erdogan is a hostile stance towards my nation,” he stated on April thirteenth. “My nation will foil this plot.”

Turkey’s relations with the EU and America are arguably at their worst in a long time. Flashpoints embrace the nation’s buy of an S-400 air defence system from Russia, armed offensives in opposition to American-backed Kurdish insurgents in Syria, accusations of American help for a coup in opposition to Mr Erdogan in 2016 and spats over maritime borders with Cyprus and Greece. Tensions would definitely subside underneath an opposition authorities. However analysts, diplomats and opposition figures dismiss the concept that Mr Erdogan’s ouster would imply a foreign-policy overhaul.

A brand new Turkish authorities dedicated to fixing the economic system, releasing some political prisoners and dismantling Mr Erdogan’s autocracy would take pleasure in loads of goodwill within the West. This might pay quick dividends, equivalent to reviving long-stalled talks on upgrading Turkey’s customs union with the EU. A change in tone from Mr Erdogan’s “Ankara First” method would additionally go down properly with NATO allies. The opposition guarantees a overseas coverage run by seasoned diplomats, and suggests it will drop Mr Erdogan’s objection to letting Sweden into NATO.

However with regard to Turkey’s relations with Russia, its perspective to Kurdish insurgents in Syria, and different sources of friction, massive modifications are unlikely. A Kilicdaroglu authorities could be unlikely to hitch sanctions in opposition to Russia or play a extra lively function in Ukraine, preferring to place itself as a mediator. There’s a sense in Turkey, shared by the ruling AK celebration and the opposition, that America is not going to stay within the area endlessly, says Nigar Goksel of the Disaster Group, a think-tank. That weakens the urge for food for confrontation with Russia. “They don’t need to stick out their necks,” says Ms Goksel, as a result of that may “danger having to face Russia alone”.

One irritant would possibly go away: the S-400 air-defence system that Mr Erdogan procured from Russia, triggering American sanctions. Sending the system to a different nation (maybe Ukraine, as some American officers have reportedly steered) is just not on the desk. However a brand new authorities might put it in storage and throw away the important thing, say opposition politicians. It might additionally reject a proposal, favoured by Mr Erdogan, for Russia to construct Turkey a second nuclear plant moreover one that’s already underneath building.

A brand new authorities could should depend on the nation’s important Kurdish celebration in parliament. However it will be in no hurry to make peace with Kurdish insurgents in northern Syria or to withdraw troops from the area. It will most likely cease eradicating elected Kurdish mayors from energy, as Mr Erdogan has achieved since 2017, and permit the discharge of imprisoned Kurdish politicians equivalent to Selahattin Demirtas, a former presidential contender. However it will proceed to battle the Kurdistan Employees’ Social gathering (PKK), an armed Kurdish group in Turkey, and its Syrian franchise the YPG, says Oytun Orhan, an analyst. Mr Kilicdaroglu and firm would search to revive relations with Bashar al-Assad, one thing Mr Erdogan, who backed the Syrian dictator’s overthrow for the previous decade, has additionally begun to discover. However that alone wouldn’t flip Turkey’s Syria coverage on its head.

The swathes of land Turkey wrested from the YPG in armed offensives in Syria are essential bargaining chips with Mr Assad’s regime. A brand new authorities wouldn’t give them up simply, says Mr Orhan. Like Mr Erdogan, the opposition plans to lean on Mr Assad to take again lots of the 3.6m Syrian refugees now in Turkey and to police Kurdish insurgents. “As soon as now we have that sort of an understanding, there could also be a time we are able to contemplate withdrawing troops from Syria,” says a senior opposition lawmaker. “However this is not going to occur in a single day.” For the West, a authorities headed by Mr Kilicdaroglu could be a a lot simpler accomplice to cope with. However well-wishers in Brussels or Washington ought to curb their enthusiasm.

© 2023, The Economist Newspaper Restricted. All rights reserved. From The Economist, printed underneath licence. The unique content material could be discovered on www.economist.com